To meet increasingly rigorous energy codes, architects use modeling tools throughout the design process. These tools and strategies are becoming as familiar as concept models, specifications, programming documents, and other pieces of the architectural trade. The struggle has been to find ways to communicate the information provided by sustainability metric tools in a clear, thoughtful, and revealing way. The graphics on the following pages represent the fruits of that struggle, tracking the design process from early-concept massing and fenestration details to post-occupancy measurements, AIA-2030-Challenge reporting, and even internal audits of firm practices. The data is invaluable for testing designers’ assumptions and giving teams and their clients new things to think about. The graphics help to communicate those things to a larger audience.
Beck: Concept Massing Studies
One of the most effective techniques in the design of a new building is to consider energy use from the very beginning of the design process. The way a building sits on its site and is oriented to the sun; prevailing breezes; and other site qualities, including the very site the building occupies — all these factors influence the energy use of the structure in dramatic ways. Architects often use energy modeling during the concept design phases to determine the massing of the structures they design; this information determines the form of the building, enhancing its performance. A church in Atlanta, Georgia approached Beck to do some studies to evaluate their existing building and help determine how much of it to demolish and how much to keep. The design team tested four schemes with various site orientations and relationships to the existing structure. In this graphic, Scheme 1 uses the existing building in its entirety with a small addition, and Scheme 3 replaces the existing building with an entirely new structure. Schemes 2 and 4 each use roughly 50 percent of the existing building. The design team looked at energy use across a variety of features such as lighting, water heating, and HVAC.
Page: Solar Insolation Studies
A building that is carefully day-lit can save significant amounts of energy by cutting the need for electric lighting, and also by optimizing the amount of light let into a space while mitigating both the positive and negative effects of solar heat gain. In Texas, where the sun is bright most of the year, the challenge is to bring in natural light while limiting the amount of solar insolation, or radiation from the sun hitting a window surface directly. This direct hit from the sun can increase cooling loads significantly, leading to increased burden on mechanical systems. For a project in the Southern U.S., Page analyzed solar insolation on a south-facing glazed facade during the early design phase. By testing various depths and spacings of horizontal shading devices, the design team was able to find a cost-effective solution to present to the client. The contrasting red and blue colors overlaid on the facade make it clear where the devices are most effective (blue is where the sun is being blocked). One can see that the large overhang is quite effective at providing shade to the windows below.
Lake|Flato: Post-Occupancy Energy Use
Energy models are only as reliable as the inputs and assumptions that go into them. Energy modeling during the design process can tell us only so much about a building’s performance. The real test lies in the post-occupancy measurements. This data can either support our assumptions, or teach us new things to consider in our future projects. In the case of the Josey Pavilion, the data did both. The Josey Pavilion is a wood-framed structure in North Texas primarily utilized for its classrooms, event space, restrooms, catering areas, and its small library. The building was certified as a Living Building in 2016: It performs at net zero energy and net zero water. The graph on top shows the energy production, and the one at bottom shows energy use, across a year (winter months are at the top). As predicted, the solar panels collect more energy during summer months, as can be seen by the wider band at the bottom of the graph on the left, and dark bands in this graph represent times of rainfall, when the panels did not produce as much energy due to cloud cover. For the energy consumption graph, the opening day in October is represented by a bright line of energy use. To the surprise of the design team, the energy use spiked in the spring, when there was significant enough rainfall to make the pumps run overtime for wastewater treatment.
Margaret Sledge, AIA, is a project architect at Lake|Flato in San Antonio.